Comparison Between Montessori & Traditional Education

Montessori Traditional
1. Child chooses materials 1. Teacher sets curriculum
2. Child sets own pace 2. Teacher sets pace
3. Child is free to explore and discover on his own 3. Teacher guides the child
4. Emphasis is on the concrete 4. Emphasis is on the abstract
5. Reality orientated 5. Much role play and fantasy
6. Specific places for materials - sense of order 6. Random placement - not necessary to return to specific place
7. Child-centred learning environment 7. Teacher-centred environment
8. Child provides own stimulus 8. Teacher provides stimuli to learning
9. Self-education through self-correcting materials 9. Use of reward and punishment in motivation
10. Recognition of sensitive periods 10. All children are treated alike
11. Multi-sensory materials to develop specific skills 11. Play materials for non-specific skills
12. Liberty to move freely around the classroom 12. Rigid rules not to move furniture and sit in designated places
13. Liberty to speak (without disturbing others) as he pleases 13. Silence is on many occasions enforced
14. Teacher's role is to guide child to act and think for himself 14. Teacher does all and child is forced to follow
15. Disorderly conduct in class is regarded as teacher's fault, who seeks it out and corrects it 15. Children are punished even if fault lies with the teacher's shortcomings.